Call for a free consultation:

(973) 785-9522

4 Ways to Get the Best Possible Personal Injury Settlement

If you are suffering from devastating injuries after an accident, the last thing on your to-do list is probably fighting with an insurance company in order to be fairly compensated for your medical bills. But the unfortunate reality is that while we’d all love for insurance companies to act in our best interest after a serious injury, their own interests will always come first. On a positive note, there are things you can do after an accident that will improve your chances of getting a fair settlement for your personal injury case. I’ll tell you more about how to get the best possible personal injury settlement below, as well as when it may be time to meet with a Passaic County personal injury attorney.

Know What Your Claim is Worth

One of the biggest mistakes I see people making after an injury is that they don’t know how much to ask for in a personal injury settlement. Then they speak to the insurance company and take an offer that is nowhere near what they need or deserve. As a rule, under no circumstances should you speak to your insurer about a settlement number before you’ve decided on the minimum settlement amount you would be willing to accept.

Tally all of your medical bills, pay you have lost from taking time off work, and any costs for treatment that will be ongoing (your doctor can help you with this number). If your case is especially complicated and you cannot estimate this number, speak with a lawyer before you discuss your case with the insurance company. They can help you determine the value of your case.

During negotiations, your minimum number should remain private: don’t let the insurance adjuster know what your minimum is. Instead, use it as a guideline during your discussions. Keep in mind that you can always change this number if, for example, you discover that an injury will be chronic rather than immediately treatable, or if you have to miss more work than anticipated.

Don’t Settle for a Lowball Offer 

It’s no secret insurance companies often try to get away with a lowball offer in the first round of negotiations. Some people fail to realize this, never research how much their claim might actually be worth, and take the lowball offer only to realize much later that they don’t have enough money to pay their medical bills.

If the insurance adjuster makes an offer that is below your minimum settlement number, don’t take it right away. Request that the adjuster explain the reasoning behind their offer amount, and make sure to write down the information they give you. This way, when responding to the offer (in writing), you can argue against any reasoning that seems incorrect or unfair. Some of the adjustor’s reasons may be legitimate, and if this is the case, it is okay to accept some of them while arguing against others. At this point, write them a counteroffer letter explaining your reasoning. Hopefully this will sway the adjustor toward a more favorable offer.

Know How to Negotiate

When trying to receive a fair settlement, it never hurts to negotiate. Often it will turn out in your favor. With a bit of negotiating, you may be able to get the settlement amount closer to what you’re looking for. But you’ll have to argue with specifics in order to influence the adjustor.

Whether you are updating your demand letter or speaking on the phone to the adjuster, make sure you refer to and emphasize the specifics of your case as much as possible. Adjusters deal with many people each day, and may not recall the important details that could move the needle in your favor. Refer them to the photos you sent of your damaged vehicle or your injuries. Remind them that the other driver was talking on their phone at the time of the accident. In addition, don’t hold back in regard to how the accident has affected your life. If you are no longer able to do an activity you used to love due to your injuries, or you have been unable to work, care for your children, or have experienced other difficulties, remind them of this.

If you do reach an agreement, make sure to put it in writing right away by sending the adjuster a letter confirming the amount you agreed on.

Stand Your Ground With Your Claim Amount

Remember that you should never lower the amount in your demand letter until the adjuster has submitted a new offer. Under no circumstances should you reduce your demand without an increase on the adjustor’s end. If the adjuster won’t budge, and their reasons for their offer are not reasonable, it's time to consider other tactics.

Unfortunately, if you have serious injuries as well as pain and suffering totaling more than a few thousand dollars, it will be difficult to get the adjustor to change their offer. This is also true if your claim includes future damages, such as ongoing medical treatment or a loss of income in years to come. In addition, if there is any question as to who was at fault for the accident, it can be hard to get the insurance company to agree to your settlement amount and may be time to seek legal help.

Get a Personal Injury Attorney on Your Team

Whether an adjuster is bullying you and trying to get you to agree to a reduced settlement amount, or they simply won’t budge in their offer, at a certain point there may come a time when you need a personal injury attorney. This is especially true if your case is more complex than the average fender-bender. For example, if you had serious injuries or there are questions about who was responsible for the accident. In these cases, a Passaic County personal injury attorney can help you negotiate so you can get back to regular life as much as possible.

Bavagnoli & Bavagnoli has been representing victims of injury settlements in Northern New Jersey for over 28 years. Our caring team prides itself on giving each and every client the individualized help they deserve. We are happy to discuss your case with you at any time.

Contact us today for a free consultation at (973) 785-9522.

Receive a free consultation on your case today



Robert J. Bavagnoli is a Passaic County attorney specializing in personal injury and real estate law. He founded Bavagnoli & Bavagnoli in 1995 where he practiced for many years alongside his brother, Ronald C. Bavagnoli (now deceased). For over 28 years, he has proudly served Northern New Jersey including Passaic County, Bergen County, and Essex County, among others, recovering millions in damages for his clients.

View Full Bio

Highest praise for the professionalism and ease of working with Robert Bavagnoli and his team! I used his services for the sale and closing of a home. He acted quickly, made the process easy and covered all the bases so I didn't have to be concerned about anything. This gentleman is a pleasure to do business with and who I want in an attorney!

- Lynda R.

Great firm for personal injury plaintiffs. The welfare of the client always comes first.

- Jonathan M.

Thorough, friendly, upbeat and very professional. They kept me informed of every decision they made.  They made me feel like I’m part of their family. I would highly recommend Robert Bavagnoli to anyone that needs the assistance.

- Earl C.

I was involved in an accident and didn't know what to do.  I decided to call Bavagnoli & Bavagnoli. They welcomed me to their firm. They were so polite and as I spoke with them and saw how friendly and polite they were it lifted me up and put my mind at ease. I wasn't scared anymore and it was an excellent experience from beginning to end.

- Tamika P.

For me the experience with Bavagnoli and Bavagnoli was wonderful!  My lawyer handled my case and it went excellent, even better than I imagined.

- Ms. Dela Cruz

The Bavagnoli & Bavagnoli Difference


  • Individualized attention
  • Clear and honest communication
  • Prompt answers to all calls
  • Your needs are our top priority
  • Respectful, compassionate treatment
  • Collaborative approach to each case
  • Over 27 years of experience
  • Millions recovered



Passaic County

  • Pompton Lakes
  • Little Falls
  • Clifton
  • Passaic
  • Paterson
  • West Paterson
  • Wayne
  • Woodland Park
  • Prospect Park
  • Preakness
  • Haledon
  • Woodland Park
  • Hawthorne

Bergen County

  • Fair Lawn
  • Rochelle Park
  • Maywood
  • Lodi
  • Garfield
  • Elmwood Park
  • East Rutherford
  • Wallington
  • Hackensack
  • Paramus

Essex County

  • Nutley
  • North Caldwell
  • Newark
  • City of Orange
  • Essex Fells
  • West Caldwell
  • Cedar Grove
  • Roseland
  • Belleville
  • Montclair
  • Glen Ridge
  • West Orange
  • Bloomfield

Bavagnoli & Bavagnoli Office

12 Furler St.
Suite 5,
Totowa, NJ 07512

Phone: (973) 785-9522


Tell Us More About Your Case

Cookies Policy

This site uses cookies to offer you a better browsing experience.

I Accept